If you had to strike a magical bargain with one water-dwelling creature, who’s your best bet? A fish-tailed flirt with a song for every emotion? A shape-shifting seal who leaves emotional wreckage like seaweed on the tide? Or a sleek horse with murder in its eyes and a loyalty problem?

Today, we're diving deep (possibly too deep) into the folklore swirl of mermaids, selkies, and kelpies—three aquatic beings who’ve haunted coastal legends, shipwrecked stories, and probably a few regrettable dating decisions. Spoiler alert: not everyone makes it out of these tales alive, dry, or emotionally stable.

And if this is your kind of storytelling nonsense, be sure to sign up for my magical monthly newsletter, Tales from the Tide, where folklore, fiction, and fantasy wash up in your inbox like enchanted driftwood:

https://lisaamooreauthor.com/mailing-list

1. Physical Features: The Anatomy of Trouble

Let’s start with the shallow stuff. Literally.

Mermaids are the original influencers of the sea. Long hair? Check. Hypnotic singing voice? Absolutely. Fish tail that’s half fashion statement, half swimming hazard? You bet. But don’t be fooled by all the glitter. In older tales, mermaids weren’t just adorable songbirds—they were sirens with razor teeth and a habit of collecting sailor souls like seashells. Depending on the legend, they were either benevolent protectors or cold-blooded bringers of doom. Ah, duality.

Selkies are what you get when folklore combines seals, fashion issues, and emotional damage. They appear as seals in the water and shed their pelts to become devastatingly attractive humans on land. The catch? If someone steals their pelt, they’re trapped in human form. Which has led to… some ethically murky love stories. Picture a romance novel where the meet-cute involves petty theft and emotional blackmail.

Kelpies are nightmare fuel shaped like ponies. These shape-shifting water spirits from Scottish lore usually appear as majestic black horses lingering near rivers and lochs. Don’t saddle up. Once you touch one, you're stuck—literally. Kelpies drag unsuspecting riders into the water, drown them, and then eat them. Sometimes they shape-shift into handsome strangers, which feels like catfishing, but with more devouring.

2. Origin Stories: Where the Water Got Weird

Every myth starts somewhere, usually with a mix of terror, superstition, and people with far too much time and not enough lifeguards.

Mermaids go all the way back to ancient Assyria, where the goddess Atargatis transformed into a mermaid out of grief and shame. The Greeks later added sirens to the mix—originally half-bird, half-woman creatures who got an aquatic makeover courtesy of medieval storytellers. By the time Disney showed up, they were singing about forks and contract law.

Selkies are the spiritual mascots of Celtic melancholy. These stories float through Scottish, Irish, and Faroese traditions, typically painting selkies as gentle, tragic figures caught between two worlds—human and seal. Their tales are often more romantic than terrifying… unless you count being married to someone because they’re hiding your skin as romantic.

Kelpies were forged straight out of Highland nightmare juice. Their entire job was to keep kids from playing near deep water. But adults weren’t safe either. In some versions, kelpies are blamed for entire disappearances—because nothing says community cohesion like blaming the magical murder horse.

3. Temperament: Would You Survive the Encounter?

Let’s be honest. If you ran into one of these creatures, how long would you last?

Mermaids are hit or miss. Some might sing you to safety. Others might smash your ship on the rocks while brushing their hair. They’re the classic frenemies of the sea. If your life depends on whether she’s in a good mood or nursing a centuries-old grudge, maybe don’t bet the boat.

Selkies won’t drown you… but they will emotionally wreck you. You fall in love, start a life, maybe raise a few kids—and then, the moment they find their skin, they’re gone. No wave goodbye. Just wet footprints and a seagull screaming at your broken heart. Sweet, but not stable.

Kelpies are straightforward: they will drown you. They will eat you. You will not be missed. A kelpie is the folklore equivalent of that one person at a party who says, “Trust me,” right before setting something on fire.

If they had dating app profiles:

Mermaid: “Looking for sailors with daddy issues. Must love long walks on the beach and doom.”

 Selkie: “Searching for my pelt. May ghost you at high tide. Emotionally complicated.”

 Kelpie: “Horse by day. Monster by dinner. Swipe right and get dragged.”

4. Pop Culture Glow-Ups: Who Got the Best PR Agent?

Not all water monsters are created equal in Hollywood’s eyes.

Mermaids have the best branding team in the business. Ariel launched a thousand bath bombs. From The Little Mermaid to the Starbucks logo to sirens in Pirates of the Caribbean, mermaids have marketing on lock. If mythical creatures had publicists, mermaids hired the best.

Selkies are less mainstream, but when they show up, they matter. Films like The Secret of Roan Inish and Song of the Sea capture their bittersweet beauty. And of course, there’s Whispers of the Selkie, where the seals aren’t always running from their past—sometimes, they’re dragging it behind them like a cursed net.

Kelpies are haunting and criminally underused. The Scorpio Races by Maggie Stiefvater deserves credit for putting these man-eating equines on the YA fantasy map. Otherwise, kelpies mostly live in nightmares and whispered Highland warnings.

5. Final Verdict: Which One Would You Trust?

Let’s recap.

If you want heartbreak with your myth, go selkie.

 If you want sparkle and song with a side of sea-salted anxiety, go mermaid.

 If you want to disappear mysteriously and never be seen again, kelpie’s your guy.

In Whispers of the Selkie, I chose to swim with the emotionally complex ones. Because sometimes the real danger isn’t in the sea—it’s in the secrets you drag ashore.

6. Want More Lore Like This?

Then you, my sea-loving soul, should definitely join Tales from the Tide, my monthly newsletter packed with folklore deep dives, behind-the-scenes peeks at my selkie-infested urban fantasy world, and the occasional sea-witch recipe for handling emotionally constipated magical creatures.

Sign up here:

https://lisaamooreauthor.com/mailing-list

References

Briggs, K. M. (1976). An Encyclopedia of Fairies: Hobgoblins, Brownies, Bogies, and Other Supernatural Creatures. Pantheon Books.

 [No DOI available; out-of-print folklore reference]

McNeill, F. M. (2004). Celtic Myth and Religion: A Study of Traditional Belief, with Newly Translated Prayers, Poems and Songs. McFarland & Company.

 [ISBN: 978-0786420895; no DOI available due to independent publisher archive]

Simpson, J., & Roud, S. (2000). A Dictionary of English Folklore. Oxford University Press.

https://doi.org/10.1093/acref/9780198607663.001.0001 (Oxford Reference Online Edition)

Stiefvater, M. (2011). The Scorpio Races. Scholastic Press.

 [No DOI available; ISBN: 978-0545224901; available at https://www.scholastic.com]

Warner, M. (1998). From the Beast to the Blonde: On Fairy Tales and Their Tellers. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

 [ISBN: 9780375706202; no DOI; publisher listing at https://us.macmillan.com/books/9780375706202]

Theoi Project. (n.d.). Sirens. Retrieved from https://www.theoi.com/Pontios/Seirenes.html

 [No DOI; permanent academic-access URL used]